Every HR advice line in Australia promises expert advice. We compared seven on the thing that matters most when a decision could end up at the Fair Work Commission: who actually answers the phone.
In this article
Of the seven HR advice lines we compared, only one is answered by employment lawyers from the first call. The other six put an HR adviser or consultant on the phone first. Three of them bring lawyers in later, when a matter gets complex or heads to a hearing.
That isn’t a criticism of advisers. Plenty of questions don’t need a lawyer. But when the question is whether you can dismiss someone, the answer you act on should come from someone who is accountable for it in law.
Key takeaways
- HR Command’s Workplace Advice Line is the only one of the seven answered by employment lawyers from the first call.
- Peninsula and BrightHR run 24/7 lines staffed by advisors. Peninsula’s legal partner handles hearings and conciliations.
- Citation HR’s consultants are backed by Citation Legal, a specialist employment law firm in the same group, for complex matters.
- Employment Hero and HappyHR both say in their own terms that their HR advice isn’t legal advice.
- Call limits vary a lot: unlimited at Peninsula and BrightHR, five a year on Business NSW’s entry membership, 15 minutes a month at HappyHR.
- Before you sign any advice contract, check the term, auto-renewal and the cost of leaving early.
The best HR advice lines in Australia, ranked
We ranked each provider on who answers first, when lawyers come in, call limits, what you can file against the employee’s record, and the contract terms. Hours are shown but weighted lower: for most HR decisions, a lawyer in business hours beats an adviser at midnight.
- 1HR CommandEmployment lawyers from the first call, weekdays 8am to 6pm
- 2Citation HRHR consultants, with a specialist employment law firm in the same group
- 3PeninsulaAdvisors 24/7, with a legal partner for hearings and conciliations
- 4Employment Hero HR AdvisoryConsultants, with representation up to the first conciliation
- 5Business NSWAdvisors, with lawyers available at hourly rates
- 6BrightHRAdvisors 24/7, built into a people management app
- 7HappyHRConsultants, up to 15 minutes by phone a month
Who answers each HR advice line, in their own words
Every description below comes from the provider’s own website, linked in the sources. Your contract may differ from what’s published, so check it.
| Provider | Who answers first | Hours | When lawyers come in | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HR Command | Award winning employment lawyers | Weekdays 8am to 6pm | From the first call | One case covers one employee issue, start to finish |
| Citation HR | “An experienced HR and employee relations professional” | 24/7 on the core line | Citation Legal, for complex or higher-risk matters, with the cost agreed first | Not published |
| Peninsula | “Dedicated advisors” | 24/7 | Irwell Law, for hearings and conciliations | Unlimited |
| Employment Hero | “Workplace consultants or HR Partners” | Weekdays 8.30am to 5.30pm | Representation up to the first conciliation conference; not court | Authorised contacts capped at 10% of headcount |
| Business NSW | “Experts in HR and Industrial Relations” | Weekdays 8.30am to 5pm | ABLA lawyers, billed hourly with a member discount | 5 calls a year on Business Insights |
| BrightHR | “Employment Relations Advisors” | 24/7 | None mentioned on its Australian pages | Unlimited |
| HappyHR | “Qualified HR consultants” | Not stated | None; its terms say the service isn’t legal advice | Up to 15 minutes by phone a month |
Employment Hero’s hours are from its scope of services document; its marketing pages list longer hours. Citation’s 24/7 hours are for its core line; foundU customers are served weekdays 8am to 9pm and Saturdays 9am to 5pm.
HR adviser or employment lawyer: why it matters who picks up
An adviser can tell you what most businesses do. A lawyer tells you what the law requires in your situation, and is accountable for that advice. Two providers say as much in their own terms. Employment Hero’s advice “cannot be relied on as legal advice”, and HappyHR’s service “does not constitute” legal advice.
The gap shows up on the hard calls. Say a manager wants to end someone’s employment two weeks before their probation finishes, and the employee raised a complaint last month. An adviser can explain how probation works. A lawyer will also spot the general protections risk in the timing, tell you what to document first, and help you get the letter right.
The usual path on an adviser line is to escalate when it gets complex. That works, but it means a second conversation, sometimes a second bill, and a delay at the moment you most need speed.
What to compare before you sign an HR advice contract
- Who answers the first call. Ask for their exact title and qualification.
- What escalation costs. Is the lawyer included, discounted, or billed by the hour?
- Hours that match your risk. 24/7 matters for shift-based businesses with overnight incidents. For warnings, dismissals and restructures, business hours with a fast response is usually enough.
- Call limits. Unlimited, capped per year, or capped per month.
- What you get in writing. Advice you can file against the employee’s record, so it’s there if a claim arrives.
- The exit. Contract term, auto-renewal and early exit fees.
The seven HR advice lines reviewed
1HR Command
The Workplace Advice Line is answered by award winning employment lawyers, weekdays 8am to 6pm. Urgent matters are usually handled within a three-hour business window, and standard questions within one to two business days.
One case covers one employee issue from first contact to resolution. The advice sits inside the HR Command platform, next to the employee’s contract, policies and history. So the lawyer sees the context, and you keep the record. HR Guides walk you through warnings, show cause and termination step by step, with the right letter at each stage.
HR Command deliberately doesn’t sell claims cover. The advice isn’t shaped by an insurer’s preference to settle, so when you’re in the right, the lawyers help you hold your position.
No lock-in, no exit fees, no auto-renewal. Plans start from $2,500 a year ex GST, and you can start a free self-service trial without a sales call.
Best forBusinesses that want legal advice before they act, not after.
Think twice ifYou need someone on the phone overnight or on weekends.
2Citation HR
Citation HR’s consultants are backed by Citation Legal, a specialist employment law firm in the same group. Citation Legal, formerly FCB Workplace Law, says three of its seven partners are accredited employment law specialists. It takes on complex or higher-risk matters, with the cost agreed before work starts.
The Advice Promise covers representation and settlements if a claim arises after you followed Citation’s advice, with terms and conditions applying. Pricing is by quote. Through foundU, the HR advice add-on starts at $4,000 a year.
Best forBusinesses that want consultant advice with a law firm close behind it.
Think twice ifYou want the lawyer at the start of the conversation.
3Peninsula
Peninsula’s advice line runs 24/7, staffed by what it calls “dedicated advisors”. It says it has over 300 advisors and consultants. Its legal partner, Irwell Law, represents clients at hearings and conciliations as part of the HR package. Peninsula Protect, which Peninsula’s terms describe as a separate financial product, offers claims cover of up to $400,000 a claim, subject to the PDS.
Pricing is by quote. Peninsula’s published terms say contracts renew automatically for the same period, with fixed rises on renewal and a 30% fee to leave early.
Best forBusinesses that want round-the-clock access and claims cover.
Think twice ifYou want a lawyer’s view before you act.
4Employment Hero HR Advisory
HR Advisory is an add-on to Employment Hero’s HR platform, at $15 per employee a month with a $300 minimum. Advice comes from workplace consultants. Representation covers unfair dismissal, general protections, bullying and harassment claims up to the first conciliation conference, and can be refused if advice wasn’t sought or followed.
Best forEmployment Hero customers who want HR advice inside the system they already use.
Think twice ifYou need legal advice, or representation beyond conciliation.
5Business NSW
Business NSW’s Workplace Advice Line is staffed by HR and industrial relations advisors, weekdays 8.30am to 5pm. Business Insights membership at $54.50 a month includes five calls a year, and extra calls come in paid bundles. Calls can be escalated to ABLA lawyers, billed hourly with a member discount. Membership also brings advocacy, events and webinars.
Best forSmall NSW businesses with an occasional question.
Think twice ifYou expect more than five calls a year.
6BrightHR
BrightAdvice is a 24/7 line staffed by Australia-based employment relations advisors, built into the BrightHR app. BrightHR is part of Peninsula Group. Optional Bright Defence cover pays up to $50,000 a claim. Pricing is by quote.
Best forSmall teams that want a simple app and a line that’s always open.
Think twice ifYour questions often need legal judgement.
7HappyHR
HappyHR includes HR support from its consultants with every plan: up to 15 minutes by phone each month, plus email and video calls. The Pro plan adds a dedicated consultant. HappyHR’s terms say the service isn’t legal advice.
Best forBusinesses that mostly need software and the odd quick question.
Think twice ifYou have a live dispute or a dismissal to manage.
How we checked
We make HR Command, so we’ve ranked ourselves first and shown why. Every fact about the other six comes from their own websites, terms and scope documents, opened on 3 and 4 November 2026 and listed in the sources below. We quote their own words for who answers the phone. Prices and terms change, and your contract may differ from what’s published. We review this page every quarter.
See how HR Command puts employment lawyers on the first call, with the contracts, policies and records to back every decision.
HR advice line FAQs
Which HR advice line is best for Australian employers?
For advice you can rely on in law, HR Command, because employment lawyers answer from the first call. For 24/7 access, Peninsula or BrightHR. For consultant advice with a law firm behind it, Citation HR.
Are HR advisers lawyers?
Usually not. Of the seven providers here, only HR Command describes its advice line as answered by lawyers. Ask any provider for the title and qualification of the person who will answer your call.
Is HR advice the same as legal advice?
No. Employment Hero and HappyHR both say in their terms that their advice isn’t legal advice. Advice from a lawyer is legal advice, and the lawyer is accountable for it.
Is a 24/7 HR advice line worth it?
For shift-based businesses with overnight incidents, it can be. Most HR decisions, like warnings, dismissals and restructures, should wait for proper advice and a clear process anyway.
How much does an HR advice line cost in Australia?
From $54.50 a month for five calls a year with Business NSW, to $15 per employee a month for Employment Hero HR Advisory, to quoted packages from Peninsula, Citation and BrightHR. HR Command plans start at $2,500 a year ex GST, with the platform included.
What should I get in writing from an HR advice line?
Anything you act on in a dismissal, warning or investigation. File it against the employee’s record, so it’s there if a claim arrives.
Sources
- Peninsula, HR advice, pricing and terms and conditions
- Citation HR, HR advice for foundU customers and Citation Legal services
- Employment Hero, scope of services and pricing
- Business NSW, Workplace Advice Line, Business Insights membership and member benefits
- BrightHR, BrightAdvice and Bright Defence
- HappyHR, HR advisory and terms
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Competitor information is taken from each provider’s published website as at 4 November 2026 and may change. HR Command works in partnership with Cowell Clarke Commercial Lawyers. For advice on your situation, HR Command clients can use the Workplace Advice Line.